Eataliano Panini & Gelato Bar Claim this business

Dave Copeon Google

7 months ago

This small, family-run Italian restaurant in the market is an absolute gem. The moment you walk through the doors, you feel like you’ve been transported straight to Italy — warm, inviting, and full of charm. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming, making you feel like part of the family from the start. The menu is diverse, with something for everyone, and every dish we tried was bursting with authentic, delicious flavors. From the atmosphere to the food to the service, everything about this place is exceptional. A true five-star experience that captures the heart and soul of Italian cuisine.

Liz Rivenburghon Google

3 months ago

My sister works in the office suite above Eataliano and recommended it to me for a dine in lunch. It was perfect. Fast and friendly service with great panini's (I got the special) and a crisp glass of chilled wine. On a return trip to FL while our mom was hospitalized we did dinner take out and once again I was impressed with everything. The eggplant parm was sublime. With a 2/2 record we went with Eataliano on our current visit and tried pizza (the arugula & prosciutto, traditional pepperoni) and the sausage and pepper stromboli. Totally to die for. Wish I lived here full time!! Can’t wait to try more!!

jisersonon Google

4 months ago

The food is excellent, however their pricing is ridiculous if you make substitutions.Their dishes come with a pasta side of the same sauce as the dish. We asked to substitute oil and garlic for the tomato sauce as my wife is diabetic. We were told there is a charge for the substitution but were not told the price. The price for the regular dish with the pasta is $26. When the dish came there was no pasta on the plate and the oil and garlic pasta was brought separately as a side. When the bill came we were charged $26 for the regular dish without the included pasta plus $14 for a small side of pasta making the cost of the dish $40. When I asked the server, she was extremely arrogant and said- i told you so. Moral- if you go, be very careful when making substitutions. I will give the server a pass, as it was our first time at the restaurant and perhaps she was having a bad day.

Mohammad Malikon Google

a year ago

I was in the area for work and saw this place. After looking over their menu, I noticed they had a dish I like (chicken sorrentina). Unfortunately they only had it on their dinner menu. I live an hour away and after a few weeks I came down with my wife for dinner. They had some outside seating and we went inside to be seated. They had about 5 empty tables and we were asked if we had reservations to which we responded that we did not. They were nice enough to seat us, but we got the small two seater table with little room on the table. Nothing seemed appealing for appetizers so we went straight for the entrees. My wife had the chicken marsala and I had the chicken sorrentina. Both dishes were disappointing. The portions for the price were small and the taste was bland. I was also expecting the chicken & eggplant for my dish to be breaded as that is how I’ve had this dish in the past. The vegetable medley that our dishes came with were the only thing that tasted good. We were offered desserts and the waitress pointed out the apple strudel in the dessert window which looked very appealing so we ordered it along with the lemoncello cake for my wife. The apple strudel came out with a small slice of the strudel rather than the whole strudel the waitress showed me. The taste was good, but such a small portion for $11 was ridiculous. My wife’s lemoncello cake also came out frozen. I’m sad to say that this place is overpriced for the food quality and food portions. I don’t see myself returning here at all.

Shaunna Eickon Google

7 months ago

This restaurant is absolutely amazingly delicious. When you walk in there you feel like family. I can honestly say I go there 2 to 3 times a week. They are so welcoming. The food is homemade and delicious. I can never say enough kind things about the owners and enough delicious things about the food so I don’t know why you’re still sitting at home and not on your way there. It is to die for!!!