Pirate's Well Restaurant & Bar Claim this business

Erin O’Neill Collinson Google

2 months ago

We had an incredible time at Pirate's Well, and a huge part of that was thanks to our server, Gia! Even though she was the only server working, you would absolutely never know it. She was incredibly quick, right on time with everything, and completely attentive. Despite the high volume of patrons in the house, she remained polite, friendly, and never once seemed rushed. The food was fantastic—great portion sizes, beautifully presented, and they have an awesome variety of specials to choose from every single day of the week. The prices are very reasonable, and the decor inside is wonderful. On top of the great food and service, they have outdoor seating, a fun mural on the wall as you walk in, and a huge parking lot with plenty of available spaces and handicap parking. We will definitely be back! Thank you, Gia, for making our visit so special!

Devin Lawrenceon Google

2 months ago

This place used to be amazing! Food was great. But in recent years it has all gone way downhill. I used to frequent pirates well with friends for some drinks and food and never had an issue. I ordered from here a few years back and the food was awful! Fast forward to today 06/29/26 and we decided to give it another try in hopes that it was just a fluke and that the food was what we remembered it to be…well bad news it sucked AGAIN! The Mott sticks were over cooked and had no cheese in them, the mac and cheese bites were absolutely disgusting and tasted like a ball of overcooked plain noodles with breading on them, the burger was sub par just looked like a frozen party thrown on a flat top and added some cheese and my once upon a time favorite, the steak fajita wrap, full of onions and peppers with little to no steak, sopping wet and the tortilla was falling apart, had 2 bites and threw it out. All for a whopping $70. Will NOT be returning. Very disappointed.

Derek H.on Google

6 months ago

I make it a point to visit the Pirate’s Well at least twice a season when I’m in the area. I recently heard that the bar had changed hands, but I can assure you that the food remains exceptional. The prices have slightly increased, but the quality of the food is still top-notch. During my recent visit, a few additional family members joined us. We started with fish dip, wings, and mozzarella sticks. For the main course, we had grouper sandwiches, burgers, fried chicken fingers, and a quesadilla. We also had a few draft beers. The portions were generous, and the seasoned fries were absolutely delicious. For five adults, the bill came to $180 before tip. We went on a Friday night around 5:30 p.m., the seating area was not crowded, and we sat right away. The bar area was crowded by the time we left. I would go here more if possible.

Sunshine Smithon Google

3 years ago

Just had a wonderful experience at the Pirates Well! Our server Jordan was wonderful, the food was delicious, establishment was clean and inviting, and the prices were right! The portions were plenty, right down to monster cup size- So nice not needing a refill! Go here!

Estefania Montalvoon Google

8 months ago

Great rum runner! Decor is amazing if you love pirates as much as I do. Staff is attentive and super fast. Will return!